Team Consensus

Live rankings · auto-refreshes every 10s

6responses

Investment Scenario

At $250K/qtr, the top-ranked ideas that fit within budget:

1. First-Party Data & CRM Activation$25K–$50K setup + ongoing2. LinkedIn B2B & Fleet Outreach$10K–$25K / quarter3. Reddit & Car-Care Communities$10K–$25K / quarter4. Off-Road Enthusiast Campaign$30K–$60K / quarter5. Sports & Weather Smart Triggers$40K–$70K / quarter6. Always-On High-Intent Retargeting$15K–$30K / quarter7. Digital Audio & Podcast Strategy$35K–$65K / quarter8. Spring Road-Trip Readiness$35K–$65K / quarter9. In-Moment Navigation Platforms$10K–$25K / quarter10. Gig Economy & CDL Data Targeting$15K–$30K / quarter11. Predictive Modeling & Attribution12. TikTok Paid Expansion$25K–$50K / quarter13. CTV & Streaming Video — Precision TV14. Premium Programmatic Video15. Meta Advantage+ Store Traffic

Fits in Budget

11 ideas

Est. Quarterly

$250K

Annual Projection

$1.0M

Top 3
4–6
7–9
10–13
Must Do
1

First-Party Data & CRM Activation

Future-proof the media strategy before third-party cookies disappear.

64 pts
⚙️Infrastructure$25K–$50K setup + ongoingAvg rank: 5.3
2

LinkedIn B2B & Fleet Outreach

One fleet contract = hundreds of tires per year. Go where fleet managers decide.

64 pts
🔹Lean Test$10K–$25K / quarterAvg rank: 5.3
3

Reddit & Car-Care Communities

Be the answer when someone asks 'where should I get my tires?'

61 pts
🔹Lean Test$10K–$25K / quarterAvg rank: 5.8
Strong Interest
4

Off-Road Enthusiast Campaign

Premium tires, passionate community, higher margins — own the off-road vertical.

59 pts
🔷Standard Test$30K–$60K / quarterAvg rank: 6.2
5

Sports & Weather Smart Triggers

Advertise only when weather and game-day signals spike tire demand.

59 pts
🔷Standard Test$40K–$70K / quarterAvg rank: 6.2
6

Always-On High-Intent Retargeting

Recover abandoned bookings — the lowest-cost revenue on the table.

58 pts
🔹Lean Test$15K–$30K / quarterAvg rank: 6.3
Worth Exploring
7

Digital Audio & Podcast Strategy

Reach drivers while they're behind the wheel — captive, attentive, in-market.

58 pts
🔷Standard Test$35K–$65K / quarterAvg rank: 6.3
8

Spring Road-Trip Readiness

Meet demand that already exists — spring is when drivers think about tires.

54 pts
🔷Standard Test$35K–$65K / quarterAvg rank: 7
9

In-Moment Navigation Platforms

Show up on Waze and GasBuddy when a driver is 5 minutes from a store.

53 pts
🔹Lean Test$10K–$25K / quarterAvg rank: 7.2
Lower Priority
10

Gig Economy & CDL Data Targeting

Uber and Lyft drivers replace tires 3x more often — and nobody's targeting them.

52 pts
🔹Lean Test$15K–$30K / quarterAvg rank: 7.3
11

Predictive Modeling & Attribution

Prove ROI to the CFO and predict where the next dollar should go.

46 pts
⚙️Infrastructure$30K–$50K setup + ongoingAvg rank: 8.3
12

TikTok Paid Expansion

Organic is already working — paid amplification is the logical next step.

17 pts
🔷Standard Test$25K–$50K / quarterAvg rank: 13.2
13

CTV & Streaming Video — Precision TV

Reach tire buyers on Netflix, Hulu, and live sports — with store visit proof.

11 pts
💎Premium Test$50K–$90K / quarterAvg rank: 14.2
14

Premium Programmatic Video

High-impact video across CTV, online video, and premium publishers — not just banner ads.

3 pts
🔷Standard Test$40K–$80K / quarterAvg rank: 15.5
15

Meta Advantage+ Store Traffic

1,100+ locations × Meta's AI = the most efficient local store visit engine available.

2 pts
🔷Standard Test$30K–$60K / quarterAvg rank: 15.7

From Rankings to Roadmap

Q1

Activate Now

Immediate priorities

1

First-Party Data & CRM Activation

$25K–$50K setup + ongoing

2

LinkedIn B2B & Fleet Outreach

$10K–$25K / quarter

3

Reddit & Car-Care Communities

$10K–$25K / quarter

Q2

Scale & Expand

Build on Q1 wins

4

Off-Road Enthusiast Campaign

$30K–$60K / quarter

5

Sports & Weather Smart Triggers

$40K–$70K / quarter

6

Always-On High-Intent Retargeting

$15K–$30K / quarter

7

Digital Audio & Podcast Strategy

$35K–$65K / quarter

H2

Test & Explore

Horizon opportunities

8

Spring Road-Trip Readiness

$35K–$65K / quarter

9

In-Moment Navigation Platforms

$10K–$25K / quarter

10

Gig Economy & CDL Data Targeting

$15K–$30K / quarter

Colling Media Perspective

Based on Q4 2025 performance data and the team's ranking consensus, we recommend leading with First-Party Data & CRM Activation, LinkedIn B2B & Fleet Outreach, Reddit & Car-Care Communities as immediate Q1 priorities — these represent the highest-confidence bets where we have proven performance signals and clear attribution paths.

The Q2 expansion tier — Off-Road Enthusiast Campaign, Sports & Weather Smart Triggers, Always-On High-Intent Retargeting, Digital Audio & Podcast Strategy — should be activated once Q1 baselines are established, allowing us to measure incremental lift and optimize budget allocation across channels. This phased approach protects against over-commitment while maintaining strategic momentum.

For the H2 horizon ideas (Spring Road-Trip Readiness, In-Moment Navigation Platforms, Gig Economy & CDL Data Targeting), we suggest structured test-and-learn frameworks with pre-defined success criteria and kill switches. This gives the team permission to experiment without open-ended risk.

Colling Media · Strategic Media & Attribution Partners

Why It's #1

Team reasoning for their top picks
Test User#Gig Economy & CDL Data Targeting

"This is a high-growth untapped segment with clear data signals."

Apple Review#First-Party Data & CRM Activation

"First-party data is the foundation — every other initiative becomes more efficient when we own the data layer."

Individual Submissions

Test05:56 AM
1LinkedIn B2B & Fleet Outreach
2Digital Audio & Podcast Strategy
3Sports & Weather Smart Triggers

+12 more

Test User05:12 AM
1Gig Economy & CDL Data Targeting
2in-banner-video
3Spring Road-Trip Readiness

+10 more

Apple Review04:52 AM
1First-Party Data & CRM Activation
2Reddit & Car-Care Communities
3In-Moment Navigation Platforms

+10 more

UX Tester03:57 AM
1LinkedIn B2B & Fleet Outreach
2Off-Road Enthusiast Campaign
3Digital Audio & Podcast Strategy

+9 more

Jordan03:28 AM
1Reddit & Car-Care Communities
2First-Party Data & CRM Activation
3Sports & Weather Smart Triggers

+9 more

QBR Tester03:12 AM
1Predictive Modeling & Attribution
2Off-Road Enthusiast Campaign
3Always-On High-Intent Retargeting

+9 more